Chrome Gemini alternative that runs locally
Short answer
Gemini in Chrome answers on Google's servers, which means the page is sent. Nightjar answers on your machine, which means it is not — at the cost of a smaller, less capable model.
The actual difference
“Some of the page content Gemini uses might not be visible to you” is Google's own sentence, and it is the most honest line in any of these documents. You cannot audit a disclosure you cannot see.
What Gemini in Chrome says about your data
- Gemini collects and processes the page content and URL of your current tab, plus other tabs you share with it.
- Some of the page content used is not necessarily visible to you.“Some of the page content Gemini uses might not be visible to you.”
- Information from websites you visit with the feature is stored in Gemini Apps Activity when Keep Activity is on.
- When Keep Activity is on, that activity is used to improve services with the help of human reviewers.
- Data reviewed by service providers is disconnected from your account and kept for three years.
- If you ask it to find pages you have visited, relevant URLs from your Chrome history are also collected.
Where Gemini in Chrome is the better choice
Gemini is a frontier model with the whole of Google behind it, and for questions that need knowledge rather than the document in front of you it is not a close contest. Chrome is also a better browser than Nightjar by most measures that are not about data.
Where Nightjar is
When the document is one you cannot send anywhere — a client file, a patient note, an unfiled application — and the question is about what the document says rather than about the world. That is a narrow case and it is the case Nightjar is built for. The rest of the time it will lose, and the limitations page says so in more detail.
Sources
Other ways people ask this
- chrome gemini alternative
- private chrome gemini alternative
- chrome gemini alternative free
- I use Chrome Gemini but I don't want Google seeing the pages I open. What's a local alternative?