Local AI versus a ChatGPT subscription
Short answer
A subscription buys a frontier model for about $240 a year, with your documents going to the vendor. A local model costs a few dollars of electricity, keeps everything on the machine, and is meaningfully less capable on hard questions.
Cost
A consumer AI subscription is typically $20 a month, so $240 a year, usually with a usage cap.
A local model costs electricity. A mid-range GPU drawing 150–200 W while generating, for an hour of actual generation a day, is roughly 60 kWh a year — somewhere around ten to twenty dollars depending where you live, and realistic use is a fraction of that. Add disk: 0.75 to 6.6 GB per model.
Capability, honestly
The subscription wins, and not narrowly. A model that fits on a consumer graphics card has single-digit billions of parameters against hundreds of billions, and on hard reasoning, code, and anything needing broad world knowledge it loses.
The gap narrows sharply on the specific task of reading a document that is already in front of the model. Our own 16-question reading evaluation had Qwen 3.5 2B — a 1.2 GB file — scoring 16 out of 16.
Speed
A hosted model is usually faster and never depends on your hardware. Local speed is yours: on our RTX 3060, 27 tokens per second for Qwen 3.5 9B and 69 for Gemma 4 E2B; with no graphics card, 15 for Qwen 3.5 2B and 2.8 for Gemma 4 12B.
Local also has no queue, no rate limit and no outage.
The part that is not about money
With a subscription, the documents you ask about are received by the vendor, under terms that can change. With a local model they are not received by anyone.
For most questions that difference is irrelevant. For a client contract, a patient note or an unfiled patent application it is the whole decision, and no price makes it go away.
What most people should actually do
Both. Use the subscription for hard thinking on things you do not mind sending, and a local model for the documents you would not paste anywhere. They are not competing for the same questions.
Other ways people ask this
- local ai free vs chatgpt plus
- How much would I save switching from ChatGPT Plus to a local model?