Nightjar Browser vs Dia
Short answer
“Improve Dia, unless you opt out” is doing a lot of work in that sentence. An opt-out is a setting you have to find; it is not the same as data that was never collected.
Dia
Dia's policy lists your assistant queries and responses, and the pages you visit, as content it processes, and says content may be used to improve Dia unless you opt out. It gives no retention period for that content.
- Queries submitted to and responses created by the Dia Assistant are listed as content data processed to provide Dia.
- The pages you visit using Dia are listed as content data.
- Content may be used to improve Dia unless you opt out.“We may also collect and use your Content to improve Dia, unless you opt out.”
- With Sync enabled, all user content is sent off the device, though the policy says it is end-to-end encrypted and not stored in readable form.
- Retention is stated only as being for as long as necessary to provide Dia, with no period given for AI content.
Nightjar
The assistant runs an open-weight model from a file on your disk. Page content, chats and attached files are not transmitted, and you can confirm that with a network monitor in about five minutes. Eleven models from 0.75 GB to 30.4 GB; on our RTX 3060, 27 tokens per second for Qwen 3.5 9B.
Where Dia wins
Dia is a better-designed browser than Nightjar in most respects that are not about privacy, and it offers an opt-out from product-improvement use, which not every vendor does. The craft in the product is obvious.
How to decide
If the document is confidential, the architecture decides it and no policy will. If it is not, pick on capability, and the hosted model usually wins. Most people should use both for different questions.
Sources
Other ways people ask this
- nightjar vs dia
- Dia vs Nightjar Browser: which keeps more data on my machine?