Skip to content

Nightjar Browser vs Firefox AI sidebar

Short answer

The sidebar is the catch, and it is an honest catch. Mozilla does not see your conversation because Mozilla is not the one answering it — the provider you picked is, under their policy, not Mozilla's.

Firefox AI features

Mozilla runs some AI features on-device with small language models and keeps the chatbot sidebar as a shell around a third-party provider you choose — so Mozilla says it does not see your conversations, and the provider does.

  • Translation and PDF alt-text run locally, with page content, PDFs, images and tab URLs staying on the device.“These operate locally — web page content, PDFs, images and tab URLs stay on your device”
  • Those local features use small language models downloaded to the device.
  • Mozilla says it does not have access to chatbot conversations.“Mozilla does not have access to your conversations or the underlying content you input into the selected chatbot.”
  • Chatbot use is governed by the chosen provider's own terms and privacy notice, not Mozilla's.
  • On mobile, Shake to Summarize runs on-device where supported; otherwise page content is sent to a Mozilla server, which Mozilla says it does not store.

Nightjar

The assistant runs an open-weight model from a file on your disk. Page content, chats and attached files are not transmitted, and you can confirm that with a network monitor in about five minutes. Eleven models from 0.75 GB to 30.4 GB; on our RTX 3060, 27 tokens per second for Qwen 3.5 9B.

Where Firefox AI features wins

Mozilla is doing the same thing Nightjar is, for the features where it is feasible, and saying so precisely. Running translation and alt-text on-device with small models is the right instinct, and Firefox is a better browser than Nightjar on every axis except this one.

How to decide

If the document is confidential, the architecture decides it and no policy will. If it is not, pick on capability, and the hosted model usually wins. Most people should use both for different questions.

Sources

Other ways people ask this

  • nightjar vs firefox ai
  • Firefox AI sidebar vs Nightjar Browser: which keeps more data on my machine?

Related