Nightjar Browser vs Ollama + Page Assist
Short answer
Both keep everything on your machine, so this is not a privacy comparison. It is a comparison of assembly: three components you maintain against one installer, against the cost of not being able to swap the pieces.
Ollama with Page Assist
A local model server plus a browser extension that gives it the page. Privately it is equivalent to Nightjar; the difference is setup, integration and who is responsible when it breaks.
Nightjar
The assistant runs an open-weight model from a file on your disk. Page content, chats and attached files are not transmitted, and you can confirm that with a network monitor in about five minutes. Eleven models from 0.75 GB to 30.4 GB; on our RTX 3060, 27 tokens per second for Qwen 3.5 9B.
Where Ollama with Page Assist wins
More flexible than Nightjar in every direction. Any model, any quantisation, a local API other tools can use, and a community that will have hit your problem already. If you want to tinker, this is better.
How to decide
If the document is confidential, the architecture decides it and no policy will. If it is not, pick on capability, and the hosted model usually wins. Most people should use both for different questions.
Other ways people ask this
- nightjar vs ollama page assist
- Ollama + Page Assist vs Nightjar Browser: which keeps more data on my machine?